This article appears in the Crookston Daily times by Mike Christopherson and proves how choosing the books that inspire most augurs well for education:
'The federal public education legislation may be called "No Child Left Behind," but teachers in Crookston's public schools say that children will end up being left behind – or bored and unchallenged – if every student is treated the same in the classroom no matter their learning level.
"You need to give your students what they need, and that's not all the same thing," third grade teacher Sara Geist told the Crookston School Board and administrators this week. "They have very different needs, and very different interests."
The local school district is on the No Child Left Behind non-Adequate Yearly Progress (AYP) list. As part of its mandated improvement plan, the district has identified four goals, and one of them is "differentiated instruction," which has been a desire of many teachers in the district long before it was listed as an official goal.
Second grade teacher Kim Davidson, who's taught for 26 years, said she's had differentiated instruction on her mind since her second year. "I got very frustrated early, because everyone was on the same page at the same time, no matter what," she said. "I ended up giving more of the same to the faster kids while I tried to help the struggling kids. I finally said, no, I can't treat them all the same."
Why? Because the struggling kids won't be able to keep up without some extra help or an extra push in the right direction, and the gifted kids will spend too much time waiting for the others to keep up, and there's a risk they'll become bored, disinterested, and they won't be presented with the challenges that their developing minds crave.
At the heart of differentiated instruction is the belief that young learners, whether they're highly skilled or at risk of falling behind, will respond academically if they're learning things that interest them. A project in Geist's class centered on the Titanic story resulted in posters of the Titanic, drawn to scale, research projects on icebergs, research into what happened to the pets on the historic ship when it sank, and even a Titanic play, with multiple acts.
"They have to do the research, they have to show what they know," Geist explained. "But they show what they know in different ways. If I had just stood there and delivered a lesson on the Titanic, I would never have gotten the complexity that reflected their interests and abilities. One story on a historic ship ended up crossing the entire curriculum."
Davidson sees boys and girls constantly who simply don't want to read. But a funny thing happens, she said, when they're allowed to choose books that cover subjects that interest them. She had boys this year who were into extreme sports and – wouldn't you know it? – their enthusiasm perked up, and their reading improved, when they read books on extreme sports.
Both Geist and Davidson utilize "ability grouping" so kids, when they're not learning individually, can do projects with classmates with similar abilities. Some of their students read with younger "reading buddies" as well, while others read with older "buddies."
At the high school, history teacher Jon Bittner is a fan of differentiated instruction, too, and said without it, there's a risk that students will disengage from the class and maybe decide to skip it entirely. At that critical stage, they’re dangerously close to falling through the cracks.
As a coach, he can't help but compare differentiated instruction to athletics. If Joe Montana had been assigned to play offensive line, Bittner said, no one probably ever would have heard of him. "Once you figure out what these kids are able to do and what their interests and talents are, you can design a model and and come up with projects in such a way where they can have some success," he explained.
World history has a lot to do with "old dead people," he said, which might not interest many students. But if a student who likes industrial arts is given a research project on tools used in a certain ancient culture, Bittner explained, there's a better chance something great will result.
But, acknowledging he can't help climbing on his soapbox at least a little bit, Bittner said differentiated instruction and all of its successes don't fit with state and federal rules that mandate standardized tests for every student, no matter how gifted they are, or how much they struggle.
"It's an enigma; we're still going to test you, we're still going to pigeonhole you and make you take a test and regurgitate all this stuff," he said. "We play by two rules: the interests of the kids, and the interests of the state and federal government."
He acknowledges that those tests are the government's only benchmark to see how students are doing academically. "But in our classroom, we have a lot of other ways to measure that," Bittner said. "For me, it's kind of rejuvenated my teaching a little bit; I'm having more fun." '
By Mike Christopherson, Managing Editor
Crookston Daily Times
Read more...
No comments:
Post a Comment